Home The Humans Upgrade Specialist AI In Practice Go Deeper Let's Talk →

Offshore M&A Help Didn't Work. Is There a Better Way?

Darren SharmaCEO & FounderNovember 18, 2026

If you tried offshore M&A support and gave up, you probably decided the provider was poor, or that offshore doesn't suit a firm like yours. There is a third explanation, and it is better news.

Most providers offer only lower value-added work: an output to a specification, such as a pitchbook, a set of comps or a model update. Higher value-added work carries the analyst's opinion: what a business is worth, and which buyers belong on the list. Both exist offshore. They are the two types of research outsourcing, and most firms only ever see the first.

If you didn't know there was a second, you are in good company. Most providers don't offer it, so it rarely comes up in a search. It has always been there, and it is becoming more popular as firms grow familiar with working offshore.

It means an analyst: a graduate of one of India's top MBA schools who works only for your firm, talks directly to your partners, and tells you what they think. This article is about how to ask for one.

The short answer

If offshore M&A support did not work for your firm, there is a better way, and it is probably not another provider of the same thing. Most offshore providers sell lower value-added work: pitchbooks, comps and model updates. A boutique that wanted a thought partner would more naturally benefit from higher value-added work, where a dedicated offshore analyst also gives an opinion on what a business is worth and who should buy it. These are the two types of research outsourcing, and each suits a different firm.

What it might have looked like from your side

The pattern is familiar. The analyst is good at taking a specific instruction and doing the task. The senior people at the provider who showed up in the first weeks have gone quiet. Work comes back that nobody seems to have checked: a buyer list with an obvious buyer missing, for example.

You find yourself catching things you thought you were paying someone else to catch. Sooner or later the conclusion writes itself. You wanted a thought partner backed by a deal team, and you are paying for an assistant who is good at Excel and PowerPoint.

It wasn't them, and it wasn't you

Three questions settle it.

  1. Was the provider bad? If you ran a structured search, compared proposals and took references, probably not. It sold what it said it would sell.
  2. Was your team unreceptive? Unlikely. A firm that goes to the trouble of a search wants it to work.
  3. What did the brief ask for? This is where the answer usually sits. A request for proposal is good at testing coverage, turnaround, software licenses, commitment term and exit terms. It is poor at testing whether the person at the other end can see the bigger picture, or whether there is a team behind them adding context from what it has seen.

You got what you asked for. The good news is in that sentence. Ask for something else and you get something else.

Why nobody offered you the other model

There are two types of offshore support.

Lower value-added outsourcing is work that carries no opinion: a pitchbook, a set of comparables, a model update. It has been a good service for two decades, and a firm that chooses it on purpose is well served. Staff at the provider are incentivized to stay in their lanes, keeping their ideas to themselves.

Higher value-added outsourcing carries the analyst's opinion: a view on what a business is worth and why, or on which buyers belong on the list. The analyst does the decks and models too, in the way a good analyst in your own office does them: as part of the job, with the context that makes the next piece better.

Most providers offer only the first. Their proposals, pricing and service levels are built around it, and a brief assembled from those proposals takes the same shape. The second model never comes into view, so nobody asks for it. Nobody chose badly. The firm drifted into the only model on the table.

That also explains what you saw:

  • Work is specified by task, so the analyst is managed to the task. (Contrast this with how you manage graduates who are new to your own firm onshore.)
  • Review sits with a delivery manager who has not done your job.
  • Senior attention is spread across many accounts, which is why it fades after the first weeks.
  • Where analyst turnover is high, what one analyst learned about your sectors leaves with them.

None of this is a fault in the person you were given. It is what the model is built to do.

What changes when you buy a higher value-added analyst

  • The analyst is recruited to the profile you set, and trained before they join your team.
  • They talk to your partners directly, with no delivery manager in between.
  • You ask what they think, and they tell you. A buyer missing from the list gets raised before the list reaches you.
  • What they learn on one mandate is still there for the next.
  • Their work is reviewed by people who have done the job.

It does not take more of your time. It is a different kind of conversation: the one you would have with a good graduate sitting down the hall.

The alternatives you will be offered

Ask around, or ask an AI assistant, and you will usually be pointed to four things.

  • Another provider. With the same brief you will find the same model under a different name.
  • AI tools. They speed up lower value-added work: comparables, first drafts, searching documents. That lowers its cost, and it is worth having. A tool will not tell you a buyer is missing from the list, or what a business is worth.
  • Freelancers and fractional analysts. Useful for a single deal. Each engagement starts cold: new templates, a new sector, new partners.
  • A hire at home. The right answer for some firms. It is the same thing you would be asking for offshore: an analyst.

The first three are good at what they do. Only the last gives you an analyst, and so does the other offshore model.

What to put in the next brief

If you come back to offshore, change the envelope of possibilities to include higher value-added work.

Three things decide what you get: who the analysts are, how they are trained and overseen, and how long they stay. Ask about each.

The analysts

  • Which school did they go to? India has roughly 1,300 MBA schools, and there is a third-party ranking: the NIRF management ranking, published each year by India's Ministry of Education. Ask for each analyst's school and look it up.
  • Where did they work before? People who have worked on live deals past the pitch stage, at the India centers of global banks, are there to be hired. So are people with a first career in the sector you cover.
  • Will they give you a view? Give a candidate a company and ask what it is worth and who should buy it. A deck shows you formatting. A view shows you whether there is an analyst.

Training and oversight

  • How much training do they get before they touch your work? Ask for the number of weeks. The answers range from about one week to three months.
  • Who oversees their work, and how closely?
  • Has the person doing the oversight done your job? Review by someone who has sat in your seat is a different thing from review by a delivery manager.
  • Who stands between you and the analyst? If the answer is a delivery manager, you are buying lower value-added work.

Retention

  • How long do analysts stay, at the firm and on one account? Ask for median tenure, and check it against the provider's LinkedIn page.
  • What happens to what they know when one leaves?

And one for your side

  • Ask yourself one question. How culturally open is your firm to consultant views? This model needs nothing rarer than partners who will ask the analyst what they think.

When lower value-added work is the right answer

If what you need is decks turned overnight to your template, lower value-added outsourcing is the right purchase, and the brief you wrote was the right brief. AI is lowering the cost of that work, so expect it to show in the price. The mismatch only matters where more was wanted.

Sometimes it was the provider. A pilot staffed with strong people who then moved on, or an analyst left without review, is a provider problem. There is a scorecard for that: how to tell if your offshore research provider is underperforming.

How to tell which one you had

The instruction test

The analyst did exactly what was asked, and nothing that was not.

The silence test

Nobody on the provider's side offered a view on one of your mandates in months.

The checking test

You were the one finding the errors.

The context test

Each new mandate started from zero. Nothing learned on the last one showed up in the next.

The departure test

If the analyst had left, nothing they knew about your sectors would have stayed behind.

If several of these are true, you had lower value-added outsourcing. If you wanted more, look at the model before you look at the people in it.

Whichever model you buy, the mandate, the client relationship and the decision stay with your partners. An analyst gives an opinion. You decide what to do with it.

For reference, median employee tenure at Frontline is 9.6 years, against 2.4 to 5.2 years at the main mass-market providers (LinkedIn, November 2026).

If the tests above describe your last engagement, the next step is a different brief: what moving to the analyst model involves.

Frequently asked questions

Why did our offshore M&A analyst only do what they were told?
Most offshore providers sell lower value-added work, where no opinion is asked for. The analyst is managed to the task, so a view was never part of what was bought. It is the model, not the person.

Is it worth trying offshore again after it did not work?
Yes, if the brief changes. The same request for proposal will find the same model. Ask who will do the work, who reviews it, and who stands between you and the analyst.

Was the problem the provider, or us?
Usually neither. A structured search finds a competent provider of what the brief describes. If the brief described decks and models and you wanted an analyst's view, both sides delivered and you were still short.

Can AI tools do what an offshore M&A analyst does?
They speed up lower value-added work such as comparables and first drafts, and that lowers its cost. They do not form a view on what a business is worth or who should buy it. That still takes an analyst.

What should an M&A boutique ask an offshore provider?
Who will do the work, and how are they recruited and trained? Who reviews it, and have they done our job? How long do analysts stay? Will the analyst give us a view, and can they defend it?

Part of: M&A and investment banking outsourcing

Compare: Two types of research outsourcing, by value added

Go deeper: How to switch offshore research provider · India-based analyst teams